Saturday, November 20, 2010

Jerry's (Wicker Park)

Welcome to the first blog posting on Eat Yo Sandwich! This is a pretty exciting moment for's like I'm taking my first baby steps into the blogosphere. Let's start with our most recent experience at Jerry's in Wicker Park.

As some of you may know, Jerry's is one of the more established sandwich spots in Chicago, which makes it a fairly appropriate destination for our first blog review. Jerry's is pretty unique in that it combines your run of the mill specialty sandwich shop with a lounge-y bar scene. They also feature hundreds of different bottled beers in addition to seasonals on tap to pair with your sandwich. Be prepared to spend at least 15 minutes browsing the sandwich choices...the options are overwhelming! Overall ambiance inside was great.  The low (but not obnoxiously low) lighting and solid blues background music helped set the mood. Let's be honest though, this isn't a restaurant review blog...on to the sandwiches!

The Mindy F
(Blackened chicken, avocado, aged cheddar, chipotle chutney on Tuscan white)

The Mindy F is one of "Jerry's Top 10" sandwiches, but does it live up to the hype? There was an interesting mix of flavors and textures in this sandwich. I loved the chipotle chutney and the aged cheddar...big, bold flavors with a hint of sweetness. The sliced blackened chicken was a bit dry and could've been a little more "blackened". While I liked the idea of avocado on this sandwich, it just didn't mesh for whatever reason. The Tuscan white bread (which we chose from a list of 9 options) also seemed dry and tasteless. Overall, not a bad choice, but didn't meet my expectations to say the least. 

The Herman M
(Ham, prosciutto, apple, brie, honey mustard on a pretzel bun)

I normally don't mix different pork products on the same sandwich (just seems wrong for some reason), but I couldn't pass up the opportunity to try another interesting combination of flavors. The Herman M, which is also included in "Jerry's Top 10," completely blew me away. I never imagined apple and ham would go so well together, but I may have to try this combo again soon. The generous portions of lean ham and proscuitto perfectly complemented the sweet flavors from the thinly sliced apples, honey mustard, and chunks of brie cheese. The sweet/salty pretzel bun was icing on the cake. Definitely one of my new favorite sandwiches!


  1. WOW!!! pretzel bun!!!??? i've never seen anything like it!!! great reviews so far! keep it up!!!

  2. Personally, I think it should be Eatcho Samwedge, but otherwise the site is amazing, sir!

    Bill Murray is the perfect way to rate sandwiches, I don't even think it needs an explanation.